Adopting Rescued or Shelter Dogs: Pros and Cons

An animal shelter is a great place to adopt a dog, and a great place to start a search for your canine companion. But adopting an animal from a shelter or a rescue group isn’t for everyone. You definitely need to think over the pros and cons as you consider commitment to a new pet.

Pros to adopting a dog from rescue or shelter

Here are a few of the wonderful reasons for adopting a dog from a shelter or a rescue group, instead of buying one from a pet store or a breeder:

  • Save one of the millions of animals euthanized in shelters every year. When you adopt a shelter animal, you give one of these adoptable dogs a second chance at a new, healthy life and a happy home.

  • Discover that the dog you thought you wanted isn’t the one you need. For example, you may think you want a puppy but discover that an older dog is calmer and better trained, so a shelter may be a much better place to find your fit.

  • Pay less for your new best friend. Adoption fees typically are far below what pet stores charge.

  • Find out more about your new dog than you can from a pet store. Responsible shelters provide you with plenty of care information, support, temperament evaluation, and more.

  • Get more specific information about a shelter animal from shelter workers. Talk to the people who have been spending time with the dog to find out about what the animal is like and what he needs.

  • Feel good about contributing to and supporting a process that supports the welfare and management of stray animals in your community. You can get involved with the process in many ways, from adopting pets to donating money to volunteering your time.

    Most shelters include many volunteers on their staffs, solicit donations, and conduct fundraisers. They often need your help. In fact, humane societies and privately run shelters usually depend almost entirely on donations and volunteers.

  • Find a lost dog. Shelters often are responsible for reuniting lost pets with their owners.

Some shelter dogs have special needs, and if you’re willing to manage those needs, you can save a dog that otherwise may not find a home — and that feels great.

Cons to rescue group or shelter dog adoptions

Truthfully, there aren’t many cons to adopting a dog from a responsible shelter or a rescue group, but you may face a few downsides. Think carefully before adopting a dog from these sources because

  • You may be unable to find the exact breed of dog you want if you’re only going to shelters.

  • You may be unable to adopt the dog you like immediately. Shelters and rescue groups often adhere to a waiting period so you don’t rush into a decision and so owners have time to reclaim any incoming animals that may be lost.

  • You’re faced with answering a lot of personal questions and submitting a lot of paperwork.

  • The organization probably isn’t rolling in dough. Just because the government funds an animal-control agency doesn’t mean it’s getting everything it needs. Some shelters are underfunded and may not be able to maintain spacious facilities or spend much time screening or training the animals. And rescue groups usually don’t even have space —animals are housed in members’ homes.

  • Your new dog may turn out much different than you expected. When you bring any animal home, you may find it’s much different than it appeared to be at the shelter.

  • Some shelter and rescue dogs have special needs that you may not be willing to deal with.

  • You may be rejected for the dog you want if you don’t meet the organization’s requirements.

Comments (3)

  1. Posted by Dawn
    One of the shelter con's that isn't mentioned is exposure to infectious disease. I adopted a dog from a shelter- two days later it showed signs of parvo infection. After three days of hospitalization with IV antibiotics and fluids, the dog died. VERY hard on the family. Many dogs that you get from a rescue or shelter have less than stellar vaccinations history and are coming into contact with lots of other dogs that may be lacking in vaccinations. I'm by no means saying don't do it, but just be aware.
  2. Posted by Rob
    Similar to the previous comment, animal shelters do NOT do complete medical checks. I adopted a dog and they had the vet check to make sure the dog was healthy and even told me "he's completely healthy." All that actually meant is that they checked if he had any obvious signs of illness. The day we brought him home we noticed something was wrong with his leg and asked if he was okay. We were told to just check back the next day if he was still limping. Long story short: it turns out his ligament was COMPLETELY torn off in one of his hind legs while the other hind leg was starting to tear as well. Surgery costs over $4000 to fix him up and I couldn't afford it at the time so I had to give him up and by that time I already was attached. Please be careful as it can be a very heartbreaking situation.
  3. Posted by Shantay
    I'm sorry to hear about the unsuccessful adoption stories, but I just hope everyone else keeps in mind that it doesn't happen all the time. Incidents like that are very unfortunate. I adopted Kona from a public shelter two years ago. He does have a couple medical issues, but overall he is a well-behaved, healthy, happy dog that was already housebroken when we brought him home. Like good/bad breeders, there are also good and bad animal rescues. I volunteer at a good one that quarantines dogs for two weeks until their vet says they are healthy and their behavior is safe for animals and people. So, basically, just give adoption a chance. I did - and it was worth it. :)