Undoing the Dewclaw

Many puppy buyers are not aware that some breeds, such as the Doberman pinscher, have their dewclaw, an unnecessary toe on the back of the leg that's an evolutionary leftover, removed to give the leg a smoother look. If you purchased your puppy from a reputable breeder, this procedure may have already been done when the puppy was three to five days old. At this age, the dog doesn't even need to be anesthetized. This procedure is one that some breeders can do themselves, with no apparent ill effect to the puppies, who recover quickly from the amputation.

icon

While many people think that docking a dog's tail is not really necessary, and many more people think that docking a dog's ears is downright cruel and should be outlawed, there is a valid reason for removing the dewclaw: Dogs injure them routinely. They serve no purpose other than getting in the way - they snag on carpets, they get caught on toys or furniture, and so on. Better to have it removed cleanly than to have your dog accidentally rip it off, causing him unnecessary pain and risking infection.

Some breeders don't automatically perform a dewclaw removal, and some dog owners prefer to leave it in place until the dog has a problem and needs to have it removed. Just remember, the procedure is considerably more complicated if you wait until your dog is older, when a veterinarian will have to perform the procedure under anesthesia. It will also require post-operative care and more expense for the dog owner.

Comments (10)

  1. Posted by Brian Wagner
    the dew claw is used in many breeds. it is most commonly used in herding dogs, agility, and racing dogs. it is very important to these dogs for agility. the herding dogs use them for agility to keep the animals (cows,sheep,etc.) together. if you remove the dew claws it reduces the agility of the dog and can lead to failure in the dogs job. the dogs in the wild use the dew claw to stay with their prey. once again if you remove it, the dog will lose the animal they are chasing because the dog does not have the agility to keep up. so dew claws have proved to be very important.
  2. Posted by TBat
    My Doberman (7mo) just had his dewclaws removed and it's been a nightmare, he already chewed through the stiches in one leg right to the bone, so we put a buster on him but were told that if he did it again we would need a 3rd operation in 2 weeks. Could you help me, there's no turning back now! thx
  3. Posted by Patience O'Donnell
    Dear Brian Wager, I am sorry to inform you that "dogs in the wild" do in actuality, NOT possess rear dew claws. Front dew claws should be present on all breeds, as it is naturally found on all foxes, wolves, dholes, dingos, coyotes, etc, and serves an important albeit usually subtle purpose. Rear dew claws are vestigial, I have never in my life witnessed a wild canine sporting them before, and having worked firsthand in a wildlife rehabilitation center, I HAVE had first-hand experience with wild canines of all sorts. Rear dew claws serve no purpose, just like when cats are born with multiple toes (some are born with seven on each foot!) and/or strange 'wing-like' projections sprouting from their shoulders. These are birth defects, the result of hundreds of years of in-breeding the domesticated animal to get certain looks and shapes and temperaments. When a cow is born with an extra leg coming out of its natural leg, is this cow bred to other cows? Certainly not! So why has it been acceptable for a dog with extra sets of dew claws to be bred into our current generation of breeds? Remove dew claws at birth. It does not matter if they 'do not pose a problem' in your eyes. They are not natural. And they WILL not serve a purpose. I guarantee it.
  4. Posted by iknow morethan patienceodonnell
    dear Patience O'Donnell, original article and brian's post are NOT about rear dew claws. All your post does is change the subject. Learn how to read.
  5. Posted by What ever...
    It doesn't matter the purpose of these dew claws. They are creepy and gross...dangly appendages that freak me out. My puppy didn't have hers removed as a baby. They should have been. Now I have a dog that has flimsy claws hanging off her legs that could get caught on something and rip! Not something I wanted to have to worry about honestly. I've learned to check for them now, as I never thought about it before because all of my previous dogs had them removed and I honestly never knew about them. Remove them. They are yucky and don't serve any real purpose!
  6. Posted by Get Your Ex Back
    After reading through this article, I just feel that I need more information on the topic. Could you share some resources ?
  7. Posted by Heartburn Home Remedy
    After reading through this article, I feel that I really need more information on the topic. Can you share some resources ?
  8. Posted by Tom
    Our female Roty has an ingrown Dew claw ? You can feel it underneath the skin. Vet missed it. She was dx as a lick granuloma(she licks that jt). Does it req surical release? removal? Tom
  9. Posted by Darla
    The dew claws do not serve a purpose, except to get in the way. Like the Vet told us, if they get caught on something, they will be ripped off and cause great pain, and possibly infection. We just had our Catahoula Leopards dew claws removed, and him being a year old was not good. He chewed thru the bandages and then took the staples out of the one leg. It wasnt a very pretty sight. But it is healing and he is doing good. Get it done when they are puppies, please.
  10. Posted by Wolf
    Leave your animals intact, unless there is no other option, please.

Leave a Reply


Post Comment

Connect with For Dummies

Sign Up for RSS Feeds

Pets

Inside Dummies.com