Online Test Banks
Score higher
See Online Test Banks
Learning anything is easy
Browse Online Courses
Mobile Apps
Learning on the go
Explore Mobile Apps
Dummies Store
Shop for books and more
Start Shopping

Compare Medicare Part D Plans and Save Big Bucks

Copyright © 2014 AARP. All rights reserved.

Most folks don’t compare Part D plans before choosing one, so most of them are paying far more than they need to for their drugs. That’s because the variation in what Part D plans charge, even for the same drug, is enormous. Many analyses of Part D plans demonstrate this point very clearly.

Checking the co-pays for just one month’s supply of a single common prescription drug — using the same dosage and quantity — in all the Part D plans offered in one state very often reveals variations in co-pays of more than $100 for a 30-day supply of the identical drug and sometimes a range of around $600 a month!

Don’t believe it? Take a look at the table, which shows three drugs and the lowest and highest co-pays that were charged for them among all Part D plans in a given state in 2013. The first two meds — Abilify and Procrit — are brand-name drugs that currently have no cheaper generic alternatives.

The third drug is the relatively new generic copy of Lipitor, once the world’s best-selling medication, which commanded high prices before facing generic competition in 2012.

Notice the gigantic range in co-pays for one month’s supply of the two brand-name drugs — from $45 to $332.50 for Abilify and from $28 to $602 for Procrit! It seems too outrageous to be true. But here’s what’s happening: The plans that charge low-to-moderate amounts require you to pay fixed dollar co-pays, whereas those that charge the mega bucks require you to pay a percentage of the cost of the drug.

This percentage (technically known as coinsurance) varies a lot among plans: anywhere from 25 to 50 percent of the cost. That doesn’t matter so much when the full price of the drug — that is, the price the plan has negotiated with the manufacturers — is relatively low.

But the full price of Procrit is more than $2,007 a month, which is why the highest-cost plan in this analysis (charging 30 percent of that price) ends up with the whopping co-pay of $602. The same, on a much smaller scale, is true of generic Lipitor. But how would you know if you didn’t compare plans head-to-head according to the drugs you take?

Another lesson here: If you need expensive drugs, avoid Part D plans that charge percentages of the cost if at all possible.

Comparing Co-pays for the Same Drugs     among Part D Plans
Drug, Dosage, and Frequency State (Number of Part D Plans) Lowest/Highest Co-pay for 30-Day Supply
Abilify, 10 mg once per day NY (24 plans) $45/$332.50
Procrit, 4,000 ml, one pkg per month FL (29 plans) $28/$602.11
Atorvastatin, 20 mg once per day CA (24 plans) $0/$14.38

Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid online plan finder, 2013

  • Add a Comment
  • Print
  • Share
blog comments powered by Disqus

Inside Sweepstakes

Win $500. Easy.